Browns 2013 Quarterback Choices

With new Head Coach Rob Chudzinski and Offensive Coordinator Norv Turner making it clear that the starting quarterback position is up for grabs next season, that means the starting QB for 2013 may or may not be on the roster at present.  Let’s take a look at what the various options are.

Free Agency/Trade

The Browns have several viable options if they want to bring in a quarterback from another team. Some make more sense than others, and some I just dislike for one reason or another. Here are the most likely moves the Browns might make from outside the team or draft:

Michael Vick – The odds are the Eagles are going to go in a different direction at QB next season (probably Nick Foles). If so, they are not going to want to pay Vick’s salary, and will look to move him/release him. Vick is probably my least favorite option. He’s injury prone, he doesn’t do well in the pocket, and he’s slowing down with age. Still, there are rumors that the Browns might make a play for him if/when he becomes available.

Ryan Mallett – There have been rumors floating since Jimmy Haslam bought the team that he was going to bring Mike Lombardi in to manage personnel, and that that would lead to Ryan Mallett being traded for from New England because of Lombardi’s ties to Bill Bellicheck. Mallett has seen very limited playing time behind Tom Brady (4 pass, 1 completion), but his raw abilities are worth looking at. He’s big, strong, and smart. He has a huge arm and has the potential to really spread the field. That said, he hasn’t started since college, and there’s not enough data to try and gauge how he’d fair in the pros. He has a lot of the same upsides as Weeden, but is much younger.

Matt Flynn – Matt Flynn lost the starting job in Seattle to rookie Russell Wilson after being the biggest target in free agency last off season. If you remember, he played exceptionally well coming off the bench for Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay. While there isn’t a ton of film to get a definitive picture, what NFL playing time he has is pretty solid. And losing the starting job to Wilson isn’t really an indictment either, as Wilson was easily one of the top 5-10 quarterbacks in the NFL last season. It will be interesting to see if the Browns make a play for Flynn.

Alex Smith – Alex Smith had his best two seasons over the past two years under coach Jim Harbough. He led the team to the NFC championship game last season, and had them off to a great start before being benched in favor of Colin Kaepernick. As with Flynn, Smith being benched isn’t really a slam on him. Kaepernick has been a huge success in his six starts, and it’s hard to argue with the move. That said, Smith has a great arm, is incredibly smart, and is a fantastic game manager. He’s not going to great chaos in the defense like a Kaepernick/RGIII, and he doesn’t have the raw QB skills of a Manning/Brady/Brees, but few do. He’s good enough to start in the NFL, and if he has a solid run game (ie Frank Gore in SF, T. Rich in Cleveland), he can be a solid leader.

The Draft

The Browns’ other option is to try and snatch up a new QB via the draft. This move is likely to not sit well with the Cleveland faithful, especially if the Browns trade up to get one of the few QBs consider to have pro level starting potential. This draft class is pretty weak on sure thing quarterbacks. Still, there are a couple options worth looking at…

Geno Smith, West Virginia – Smith is 6’3″, 220 pounds, and FAST. He put up some eye popping stats last season, on a less than stellar West Virginia. If Chip Kelly had become the Browns’ head coach, I would have put money on him drafting Smith.

Matt Barkley, USC  – If Matt Barkley had joined last year’s draft class, he probably would have been a top 5-10 overall pick. He had a rough senior year, so his draft stock has taken a hit, although he’s still expected to go in the first round. At 6’2″, 230 lbs, he’s got a solid frame and great pocket passer mechanics. I think a team could really build him up if they invested a few years in to him.

Tyler Wilson, Arkansas  – Wilson is expected to go near the end of the first round, possible early second round. He’s got a solid skill set, and at 6’2″ 218 lbs, hes big enough to play in the pros. Some team might take a shot at him to develop him later on.

Mike Glennon, North Carolina State  – At 6’7″, 220 lbs, it’s not hard to see what has some NFL teams considering Glennon. He’s massive, hard to hurt, and can stand tall and absorb hits in the pocket all day. Not as slow as you’d expect for a guy with his frame, and he has a big arm and can really air it out. He might be the dark horse to surprise people out of this draft class.

On the Roster

Weeden/McCoy Brandon Weeden still has the best shot at retaining his job as the starting QB, in my opinion. It’s hard to see the Browns calling it quits on a 1st round pick after only a season, but the team’s noncommittal voice on Weeden certainly shows a lack of love for him. McCoy is a study in contrast to Weeden, and I won’t rule out a return. Weeden has the size of a typical NFL QB, a huge arm and a good pocket presence. McCoy is smaller, but faster. He can’t air it out like Weeden, but his is significantly more accurate. If the Browns want to run more of a read option type offense, McCoy should be their guy. If they want to stick to a more typical pro style or west coast type offense, Weeden will improve his odds to get another shot under center.


5 thoughts on “Browns 2013 Quarterback Choices

  1. it just doesnt make sence to take a first round pick and put it on an alex smith, or ryan mallet…. When we used a first round pick like it or not on weeden. We have to give to weeden a chance with Norv, get us a shut down corner in the draft and maybe a nice vet WR (greg jennings? we wish).. Then develop some QB with late round draft picks …. its bad business to do anything


    • Its not going to change the fact that Weeden is not an elite QB. He never will be. He’ll be at best mediocre. Why waste more time on a guy who’s never going to get you a championship?


  2. I don’t think it can be understated how Barkley taking himself out of last year’s draft changed the complexion of that first round. Perhaps Washington still leapfrogs to take RGIII, but the Browns may have still been able to take Barkley themselves or are presented a more enticing trade package from another team for that pick, and so forth. Given the multitude of scenarios, I can empathize why it made too much sense for him at the time to go back to school for another year and pad the stats and establish himself as the standout #1. He may have had Geno in his rearview, but not so close behind that his season wasn’t the relative surprise that it was.

    I got to see Glennon in person when he just arrived at NC State and Russell Wilson was still there. Even then, he exuded a Roethlisberger-type physicality which, in my humble opinion, is much more attractive to me than the hybrid style we’ve been seeing more of. Of course, give it a few years when we see the kind of health and careers Newton and others have compared to Vick and that could change.

    Mallett is the most sensible option to me as far as options outside of the organization go. He’s learned under the best QB, coach, and system and has a higher ceiling than Flynn to me. I’m making that comparison because their careers have mirrored each other the closest of the names listed.

    Is Weeden the answer? No. Will he still be first on the depth chart when camp starts? I think so simply for the same reason that the organization made an investment in him with that first-round pick. For better or worse, they’ll run that into the ground. The flipside to that is that the FO hasn’t shown me a lot of transparency since the ownership change either, so what’s said and what’s actually going on could be very different pictures. The thing is, I don’t think they’ll take a hit in the PR department if they DO decide to go with another quarterback as there’s been opposition to the Weeden pick from the get-go. Keeping both him and McCoy, however, doesn’t seem like the most sound decision for either the QBs themselves or the incoming coaching staff. Even still, I’m just kind of fed up with the whole “big time rookie starter/grizzled, seasoned veteran backup” shtick already considering we’ve yet to see that combo work out in earnest here.


    • I pretty much agree with this in its entirety. Glennon really is intriguing to me, if for no other reason than I think he’ll stay healthy, while I doubt guys like RGIII/Wilson/Geno/Vick/etc stay healthy or last long in the league.

      The problem with the big time roookie QB’s, at least in Cleveland, is that we have consistently picked them wrong/put them behind horrid O-Line’s. Like, we’ve never gone with a Luck/RGIII kind of sure fire, 1st overall pick kind of guy.


Bark Right Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s